
I'd like to believe I'm my daughter's best friend. She spends almost every waking moment with me. I know all kinds of silly tricks to make her laugh. I know her favorite foods, her favorite color, her favorite books, her favorite everything. I can interpret her facial expressions. I tell my husband I can read her mind, but that's mostly just to freak him out. I come pretty close, though. I'm the only person she's ever puked on, and I've had that honor about 10 times so far.
But still, if I'm really honest with myself, I probably have to admit that as far as she's concerned, her best friend is a worn teddy a friend sent as a gift right after she was born. I named this bear Butter because she's butter-yellow with a butterfly on her head. For Riley, it was love at first sight. She can't sleep without Butter. She squawks with delight when she sees this bear. She occasionally ensures parental attention when she should be sleeping by tossing Butter out of her crib, then crying because she can't sleep without her. (A brilliant ploy, really.) When she does go down, she holds Butter close in her hand as she sucks her thumb, so Butter gets slobbered on and rubbed during each trip to the Land of Nod.
So almost 14 months into Riley's and Butter's lives, Butter is looking pretty worn. She's been washed several times, occasionally because she's the only other entity Riley has ever barfed on.
Given the nature of Butter's work and her vital role in domestic security, my husband and I were advised by several babyologists that we should invest in a backup Butter. Internet searches yielded a clone on auction at Ebay. The starting bid was $1.99; I placed it, then waited out the sale for the next six days. I considered emailing the seller and offering her $10 for the bear to buy it outright. Each time I logged on, I held my breath as I checked my inbox to see if I was outbid. Miraculously, it never happened. My nerves were wracked at the thought that some nefarious auction-watcher was waiting till the last few minutes of the sale to jack the price into the triple digits, then outbid me at the last possible second.
Fortunately my imagination is much wilder than any current market demand for Beanie Babies. My bid of $1.99 won the day, and $6 in shipping and handling later, I Can't Believe It's Not Butter was on her way from Florida. But would Riley believe she was Butter? That was the scariest hurdle yet.
We soon had no choice but to test the waters. One morning on the changing table, Riley mounted a full-out offensive to go over the wall and make a break for freedom. She also launched a nuclear diaper, and Butter was pulled into the fallout zone. Given the noxious nature of Riley's biological warfare, Butter had to go into the wash. She wouldn't be clean by the time Riley's nap rolled around, so I Can't Believe It's Not Butter was called up from the reserves.
After stealthfully cutting off the tags and giving her a few test squeezes, I presented her to Riley. She squealed with glee, popped her thumb in her mouth and happily went down for a nap. All the while, the real Butter tumbled on a delicate setting in the dryer. I was so relieved, I called my husband at work to share the joyous news. This is cause for celebration, especially if it means my future vomit stains will be decreased by a third.